Home/Smoke control/Our projects/ISI — Offices — Grande Armée
Project · Smoke control

ISI — Offices — Grande Armée.

Smoke-evacuation study for a potential fire in offices: ensuring safe escape routes and compliance with fire-safety standards.

Project
Office building — Grande Armée
Year
2023
Client
NC
Location
Paris
Typology
Smoke control engineering
Discuss a project

Smoke-evacuation study in offices

The mission carried out by EOLIOS Engineering

As part of a new fit-out, the aim of this smoke-control study is to determine whether installing new partitioning allows smoke and combustion products to be removed from the building safely and optimally in the event of fire.

In a fire, smoke builds up and spreads: it can cause the obstruction of escape routes and emergency exits, due to heat, fumes and poor visibility. The project relies on the labour code to ensure proper smoke control of the compartments, placing full-height barriers and complying with the LCPP ASET and RSET references.

The essentials. ISI smoke-control study of an office building on avenue de la Grande Armée (Paris): validation of a new partition layout created from an open space, through a deterministic analysis under ISO 23932, with 3 unfavourable fire scenarios per compartment, in accordance with the LCPP TAC and TMSP references.

3D model · ~10 cm scaleStandard · ISO 23932References · LCPP TAC & TMSPFire · office scenario
10 cm
Modelling scale
3
Unfavourable scenarios per compartment
TAC · TMSP
LCPP references met

3D modelling for the natural smoke-control study

Since the purpose of the model is smoke control, particular care is taken first with the interconnections between the building's different spaces (stairwells, walkways, doors…), and second with all elements that may disturb the passage of smoke (transoms, doors…).

Our studies rely on modelling the building at roughly a 10 cm scale. All spaces in direct aeraulic communication are modelled, the study covering all of these spaces — working independently by compartment, without constraining the study area through an overly reduced scale effect.

Definition · ISI

Fire safety engineering covers the studies that demonstrate, through simulation, that the life-safety objectives are met. See our fire safety engineering expertise.

3D model of the office partitioning
3D model of the office partitioning

Modelling the smoke-control system

Accounting for the smoke-control system is particularly important. It involves two steps: the geometric consideration of the openings and the airflow rate of the openings.

The smoke-control openings are modelled to scale with their joinery. CFD automatically computes the flow rates according to the prevailing wind and the temperature rise in the compartments: no fixed flow condition is imposed on the windows facing outside. The openings are modelled scrupulously from the architect's drawings — this typology must be respected for the conclusions to remain valid.

Simulation of smoke distribution in offices during a fire</div><figcaption>Simulation of smoke distribution in offices during a fire</figcaption></figure>
      <div class=

Fire-source positions

EOLIOS engineers simulate different types of fire depending on the site under study; here, a typical office fire was modelled. The project aims to ensure the smoke-control systems are sized to meet the protection objectives, through representative scenarios positioned according to specific constraints:

  • Maximise the smoke path between the fire source and the nearest vent
  • Maximise the detection time and delay discovery of the fire
  • Block the use of an emergency exit or escape route
  • Promote the build-up of heat and smoke in a specific area

Methodology: ISO 23932 deterministic analysis

This refurbishment project creates new internal partitions from an open space. Smoke moves by following the airflow generated by the fire: the heat produced creates a suction current that draws smoke towards the ceiling and then through the room; depending on the wind, a slight imbalance draws the smoke towards the openings of the opposite façades.

In the sense of the ISO 23932 standard, the study relied on a deterministic risk analysis. A standardised method made it possible to identify a manageable set of design fire scenarios: the study was built around 3 deterministic (worst-case) scenarios per compartment.

Definition · Deterministic analysis

An ISO 23932 approach that studies a limited number of design fire scenarios, chosen for being unfavourable and representative, rather than a probabilistic approach covering every possible occurrence.

Definition · TMSP & TAC

LCPP references: the TMSP is the time needed for occupants to reach safety, the TAC the time at which critical conditions are reached (visibility, temperature, toxicity). Safety is demonstrated when the TMSP remains below the TAC with a sufficient margin.

Deterministic analysis — master diagram of the FSE process
Deterministic analysis — master diagram of the FSE process

Study conclusions

Across the scenarios, smoke could rush quickly into the corridors (faster obstruction of escape routes), or build up as a layer under the ceiling and move more typically towards the opposite façade. EOLIOS engineers brought their expertise to validate a new design proposed by the client, ensuring both the aesthetics and a calm, optimised evacuation of staff.

Key takeaway. Smoke inhalation is the leading cause of death in fires: controlling its propagation is the central challenge of smoke control. The conclusions remain tied to the vent typology and partitioning as modelled; any change to the project requires the study to be updated.

Expertise: smoke-control engineering
FAQ

Office smoke control — your questions

Re-partitioning, fire scenarios, ISO 23932 and validity of the conclusions: answers to the questions this type of study raises.

Why a smoke-control study for a simple office re-partitioning?

New partitions created from an open space change the paths smoke will follow: corridors, transoms and doors can speed up smoke-logging of escape routes. The study verifies, under the French labour code, that smoke extraction remains effective in every compartment and that evacuation stays safe. See also the objectives of smoke control.

How are the fire sources positioned?

According to deliberately unfavourable constraints: maximising the smoke path to the nearest vent, maximising detection time, delaying discovery of the fire, blocking an emergency exit, or promoting heat build-up in a given zone. A classic office fire was modelled.

What is a deterministic analysis under ISO 23932?

A standardised method for identifying a manageable set of design fire scenarios, chosen with the stakeholders. Here, the study was built around 3 unfavourable scenarios per compartment.

How are the vent flow rates calculated?

No fixed flow rate is imposed on windows opening to the outside: the simulation automatically computes the flows from the prevailing wind and the temperature rise in the compartments, the vents being modelled to scale with their joinery.

Do the conclusions remain valid if the project changes?

They remain valid as long as the vent typology modelled from the architects' plans is respected. Any change to the vents or partitioning requires the study to be updated.

Summary

Video summary of the study

CFD smoke-control study of an office building (Grande Armée, Paris): detailed 3D modelling of the compartments and openings, ISO 23932 deterministic analysis over 3 scenarios per compartment, and validation of the new partitioning for safe smoke evacuation.

Video summary of the mission — FSE Offices Grande Armée · EOLIOS Engineering
Discover other projects

Our other smoke control projects.

All projects
Explore the field

Smoke control: continue exploring.

CFD expertise, delivered projects and technical dossiers: the whole Smoke control field in one place.

CFDExpert engineers
20+Countries
R&DResearch & innovation
Contact

A smoke-control challenge?

The easiest way is to talk it through together. Our engineers will reply with an initial technical read.